14. Hindistan başbakanı (2014–görevde)
PM Modi leads foundation stone-laying ceremony for Philippines’ oldest gurudwara’s redevelopment
PM Narendra Modi, who is on a three-day visit to the Philippines, said he felt "very blessed" to visit the over a century-old Gurudwara Khalsa Diwan in Manila
Being civil to begin with
THAT Pakistan is sending a minister to attend the SCO Civilisational Dialogue in New Delhi on Nov 20 should be applauded even if it’s not clear that this could be the proverbial ice breaker between the perpetually aloof neighbours. It is, however, worth hoping for. The agenda for a civilisational dialogue should be fun for the participants, although India’s decade-old Hindu revivalist government may drag its feet on the issue. Bilateral ties can still improve despite this handicap. Reports are circulating of cross-border trade also picking up — albeit discreetly — between India and Pakistan in recent days. Renowned political analyst Trita Parsi used a phrase to describe the options for a low-key US retreat from the war-torn Gulf region, which may be relevant for India-Pakistan ties. Parsi likened Donald Trump’s options for a face-saving pullout from his self-created mess to Swiss cheese. Sanctions on paper and holes inside, like the bubbles within a good Swiss cheese. The US could keep its formal sanctions on the books so the administration can publicly claim it is still maintaining pressure on Tehran. In reality, the enforcement is invisibly relaxed. Which is what might work, if nothing else does, for the South Asian neighbours — an unannounced, even surreptitious discarding of different stages of hostilities. Behind the scenes, in Parsi’s version of a workable Gulf resolution, the US gradually loosens its naval blockade and stops aggressively enforcing sanctions. This creates large “holes” in the economic pressure — much like the Swiss cheese — allowing Asian, Middle Eastern, and Gulf countries to resume trading with and investing in Iran without fear of US retaliation. At some opportune moment, even if the currently tense atmosphere results in another catastrophic flare-up, peace would be the only game in town, possibly giving credence to Trita Parsi’s face-saving device. The immediate trigger for the latest round of signalling, if it indeed adds up to some kind of undeclared rapprochement, springs from very practical and commonsensical exigencies that require all neighbours to collectively deal with the huge economic challenges dogging the world. The platform offered by the SCO has been used and abused by both sides in the past to launch verbal attacks on each other. Could the tide have turned? The agenda at hand for Dr Musadik Malik, Federal Minister for Climate Change and Environmental Coordination, representing Pakistan at the meeting could present challenges as well as chances to resolve them. However, the larger theme of a civilisational dialogue that brings all SCO members together may have to confront some predictable handwringing from India. An unannounced, even surreptitious discarding of different stages of hostilities could work for South Asia. The idea of civilisation imagines a palpable and unbroken link between the past and the present. In its understanding of India’s past, however, the Hindutva establishment in New Delhi has manufactured demons to comply with a narrow political agenda. Its search for a golden past requires changing names of streets, and identifying, abusing and occasionally lynching the conjured enemy. Pakistan has been through this motion in the past. That’s when schoolchildren were given controversial ideas about non-Muslims. An instructive moment came when a Muslim journalist from India who accompanied Atal Bihari Vajpayee on his visit to Pakistan in 1978 went with his colleagues to meet his cousins. At the emotional meeting, they also wanted to know discreetly if K.K. Katyal, Raghu Rai and Sumit Chakravarty were Hindu. “But they are just like us,” one cousin reportedly observed after being told of their Hindu identities. Today many centres in Pakistan are exploring and retrieving old names of their neighbourhoods with a view to restoring their Hindu or other non-Muslim identity. India, with the advent of Narendra Modi, is heading in the opposite direction. Mughal rule is being airbrushed from school curriculum. If more Indians could travel to Pakistan they would be able to see things similar to what I saw. A few days before the Lahore summit, I travelled with Sushma Swaraj and K.R. Malkani to the fabled Katas Raj Temple abutting the Lahore-Islamabad motorway. Malkani, an atheist, stood there looking amused as Swaraj dipped her hands into the sacred pond thought to have been used by the Pandavas during their exile. The caring way this temple and countless others have been preserved for Indian tourists will make more sense when people travel across the borders. This is not to say that minorities don’t face prejudice in Pakistan. Pakistani human rights activists have spoken strongly against forcible marriage of Hindu girls. The government has made some laws to deter the phenomenon but its impact is not uniformly felt. The prevalent bigotry on the Indian side finds state support often enough as it assumes the form of homes, mosques and churches being vandalised or bulldozed accompanied by the occasional lynching of individuals from minorities. There seems to be a competition between bigots from both sides. At the SCO dialogue, a two-day session will centre on civilisational and cultural expression, art and architecture, language and literature, and religious and philosophical traditions. Delegates will also deliberate on filing joint multinational nominations for Unesco World Heritage recognition based on centuries of shared cultural exchange. Much of this will be problematic for the current ruling dispensation in India. In 2015, it had dubiously rejected a Unesco plan to declare Delhi a World Heritage City encompassing Old Delhi with its Mughal-era icons and British-era Lutyens’ New Delhi. To conclude, a telling story from the Maldives where Muslim zealots set fire to a Pakistani pavilion during a 2011 Saarc event and India watched the mayhem without a word of camaraderie with Pakistan. The event involved a display of national cultural treasures by Saarc states. Pakistan showcased its Buddhist heritage with tableaux of relics from Moenjodaro’s Indus civilisation. Extremists set fire to the Pakistan pavilion. The SCO dialogue offers as good an occasion as any to make amends to this witless aloofness between the two. The writer is Dawn’s correspondent in Delhi. jawednaqvi@gmail.com Published in Dawn, November 17th, 2026
Being civil to begin withWhy has the drive to verify India's billion voters put the poll body under scrutiny?
India’s drive to verify the eligibility of roughly a billion voters has put the country’s election authority under severe public scrutiny, with opposition parties alleging the manipulation of voter rolls and exclusion of millions. A report published in September by the Indian Express newspaper alleged there were internal divisions within the Election Commission of India (ECI) over the lists and registration procedures, stoking further concerns about its neutrality. Here’s an explainer on the ongoing controversy. Verifying a billion voters: The controversy India started verification of its voter rolls last year ahead of elections in the eastern state of Bihar. The review has now covered the majority of Indian states. While voter roll revisions are routine, this round became controversial after large numbers of voters in states such as Bihar and West Bengal found their names missing from electoral rolls and were unable to cast ballots. Opposition parties including Congress have accused Chief Election Commissioner Gyanesh Kumar of bias and alleged that the process benefits Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP). The poll body and the BJP denied such claims. The Indian Express story said two top election commissioners had expressed concerns to Kumar at least 14 times in 10 months but those concerns were not taken into consideration. The ECI said all its decisions were lawful and differing views within the commission were not unusual. The report prompted widespread protests last month by some opposition groups, student organisations, and the youth-led Cockroach Janta Party to demand Kumar’s resignation. Why does it matter? The verification drive resulted in about 130 million people being excluded from the first draft list, who are now required to prove their credentials before being enrolled. ECI data showed that about 6.5 million voters were excluded from the draft rolls during Bihar’s revision exercise last year. India’s Supreme Court has also raised concerns, saying notices to prove eligibility sent to some voters appeared to have been “machine generated” without human intervention, local media reported. What happens to voters expelled from the list? The ECI says names are only removed when a voter has died, is mentioned more than once on the rolls, has moved to another region or is untraceable. Officers are required to record detailed reasons why a voter is deleted. People whose names do not appear in draft rolls can request inclusion before final voter lists are published and also raise appeals if such requests are denied. Voters excluded from final rolls can also challenge the decision. To participate in future elections, excluded voters must succeed in their appeals or apply for fresh registration. Opposition parties argue that arbitrary deletions and lengthy appeals prevented millions in Bihar and West Bengal from voting and could be used as a weapon in future elections. Key state election due: at least seven Indian states will hold elections next year, including Uttar Pradesh, considered a bellwether state in national politics. Verification in Uttar Pradesh began in October 2025 and saw 13 per cent of names being deleted, according to local media reports. Poll body’s defence: The ECI has defended itself against allegations of political bias, including in a rare press conference last year by Kumar, who asked the opposition to submit their allegations under oath. Following the newspaper report, the poll body also announced revisions to the process including home visits by officials to collect verification documents and an extension of the deadline for final verification in some states.
Why has the drive to verify India's billion voters put the poll body under scrutiny?India blocks over 100 speakers from opposition democracy summit
India blocked more than 100 international speakers from attending a democracy summit organised by the opposition Congress party, a senior opposition politician said on Friday. Those denied visas included a Norwegian journalist who had previously questioned Prime Minister Narendra Modi about press freedom. Shashi Tharoor, a Congress MP and former senior United Nations official, said 115 of the 315 speakers cleared by India’s foreign ministry were subsequently refused entry or had their visas cancelled, “apparently on the instructions” of the home ministry. “It is completely unclear under what provision of law the government has taken such a drastic step,” Tharoor wrote on X. “What a shame that a proud democracy has become so insecure that it must stifle any voices it fears will be critical!” he added. Asked about the apparent denials, a foreign ministry spokesperson said “visa matters are sovereign functions of any country or any government”. Norwegian journalist Helle Lyng said on Wednesday that her visa was cancelled shortly before she was due to travel to India, where she had been invited to speak on media and press freedom. She had questioned Modi at a press briefing during his visit to Oslo in May. The Editors Guild of India condemned the cancellation, saying the move smacked of “bureaucratic overreach” and calling on the government to disclose its reasons and reverse the decision. The two-day summit, which opened on Friday in the city of Hyderabad, brings together around 1,000 delegates from more than 70 countries to discuss democracy, climate change, artificial intelligence and global cooperation.
India news : Modi government approves $340 million museum in Delhi
The government says that the 'Yuge Yugeen Bharat Museum' will have the world's "largest" museum dispaly area." DW has the latest.
BJP accuses Sonia Gandhi of ‘camouflaging Congress sins’ in memoir
NEW DELHI: India’s ruling Bharatiya Janata Party has accused opposition leader Sonia Gandhi of whitewashing historical wrongs by her Congress party in a memoir, sparking a new faceoff between the two sides ahead of key state elections. Congress party leaders have in turn accused Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s BJP of trying to create a spectacle and give the book a “political spin”. Titled Belonging and released on Tuesday, the memoir captures Italian-born Gandhi’s journey from her student days in England, where she met her husband and Nehru-Gandhi dynasty scion Rajiv, to her integration into India’s most powerful political family that gave the country three prime ministers. Gandhi, 79, herself turned down the prime minister’s job in 2004, but her family continues to control the party that has ruled India for periods totalling nearly 55 years since independence from British colonial rule in 1947. “Sonia Gandhi could have titled her memoir ‘Whitewashing’, instead of ‘Belonging’ because the motive of this book appears to be sugar-coating the historical wrongs perpetrated by the Nehru-Gandhi family, and camouflaging the cardinal sins committed by the Congress party,” BJP spokesperson C.R. Kesavan said in a video statement. Kesavan cited the anti-Sikh riots of 1984 which erupted after then-prime minister and Sonia’s mother-in-law Indira Gandhi was assassinated by Sikh bodyguards. Nearly 3,000 people were killed. Rights activists accuse Congress of turning a blind eye and say that some party leaders helped orchestrate the carnage. Personal memoir In the book, Sonia describes the riots as a tragic and shameful chapter, accusing some officials of looking the other way or even fuelling the violence. She defends husband Rajiv who succeeded his mother as prime minister against allegations of complicity, while acknowledging failures of governance and delayed justice. Kesavan accused Sonia of trying to “normalise and justify” the notorious Emergency imposed by Indira. The 21-month state of Emergency in 1975 involved suspending civil liberties, censoring the press and jailing opposition leaders in one of the most controversial periods of India’s history. Sonia writes that Indira felt increasingly isolated and politically cornered before imposing the Emergency. She says Indira was never entirely comfortable with it but felt compelled to continue it amid the prevailing political turmoil. Although Sonia has herself not responded to the accusations, she said in the book’s prologue that it is a “personal memoir, one for which politics is the background, a kind of framework”. Bestseller book The release comes at a time when Congress is leading the charge against Modi’s government over a controversial revision of voter lists, with Sonia’s son Rahul at the helm. The street protests have emerged as the worst political crisis for Modi since he came to power in 2014, and ahead of elections in the key states of Uttar Pradesh and Sikh-majority Punjab early next year. The book has dominated social media conversations with posts praising and criticising it in equal measure, mirroring the country’s political divide. The book has also been covered extensively by newspapers, with many publishing excerpts about major events over the last half a century. On Wednesday, the book considered expensive at $14 topped Amazon India’s bestseller list. Published in Dawn, November 12th, 2026
BJP accuses Sonia of ‘camouflaging Congress sins’ in memoir
NEW DELHI: India’s ruling Bharatiya Janata Party has accused opposition leader Sonia Gandhi of whitewashing historical wrongs by her Congress party in a memoir, sparking a new faceoff between the two sides ahead of key state elections. Congress party leaders have in turn accused Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s BJP of trying to create a spectacle and give the book a “political spin”. Titled Belonging and released on Tuesday, the memoir captures Italian-born Gandhi’s journey from her student days in England, where she met her husband and Nehru-Gandhi dynasty scion Rajiv, to her integration into India’s most powerful political family that gave the country three prime ministers. Gandhi, 79, herself turned down the prime minister’s job in 2004, but her family continues to control the party that has ruled India for periods totalling nearly 55 years since independence from British colonial rule in 1947. “Sonia Gandhi could have titled her memoir ‘Whitewashing’, instead of ‘Belonging’ because the motive of this book appears to be sugar-coating the historical wrongs perpetrated by the Nehru-Gandhi family, and camouflaging the cardinal sins committed by the Congress party,” BJP spokesperson C.R. Kesavan said in a video statement. Kesavan cited the anti-Sikh riots of 1984 which erupted after then-prime minister and Sonia’s mother-in-law Indira Gandhi was assassinated by Sikh bodyguards. Nearly 3,000 people were killed. Rights activists accuse Congress of turning a blind eye and say that some party leaders helped orchestrate the carnage. Personal memoir In the book, Sonia describes the riots as a tragic and shameful chapter, accusing some officials of looking the other way or even fuelling the violence. She defends husband Rajiv who succeeded his mother as prime minister against allegations of complicity, while acknowledging failures of governance and delayed justice. Kesavan accused Sonia of trying to “normalise and justify” the notorious Emergency imposed by Indira. The 21-month state of Emergency in 1975 involved suspending civil liberties, censoring the press and jailing opposition leaders in one of the most controversial periods of India’s history. Sonia writes that Indira felt increasingly isolated and politically cornered before imposing the Emergency. She says Indira was never entirely comfortable with it but felt compelled to continue it amid the prevailing political turmoil. Although Sonia has herself not responded to the accusations, she said in the book’s prologue that it is a “personal memoir, one for which politics is the background, a kind of framework”. Bestseller book The release comes at a time when Congress is leading the charge against Modi’s government over a controversial revision of voter lists, with Sonia’s son Rahul at the helm. The street protests have emerged as the worst political crisis for Modi since he came to power in 2014, and ahead of elections in the key states of Uttar Pradesh and Sikh-majority Punjab early next year. The book has dominated social media conversations with posts praising and criticising it in equal measure, mirroring the country’s political divide. The book has also been covered extensively by newspapers, with many publishing excerpts about major events over the last half a century. On Wednesday, the book considered expensive at $14 topped Amazon India’s bestseller list. Published in Dawn, November 12th, 2026
Louvre ve British Museum’u geride bırakacak: İşte dünyanın yeni en büyük müzesi!
HABER MERKEZİ/Hindistan hükümeti Çarşamba günü, ülkenin tarihini ve medeniyetini sergileyecek devasa bir müzenin yapımını onayladı. Kabine tarafından onaylanan ve tamamlandığında sergileme alanı bakımından dünyanın en büyük müzesi unvanını alacak olan "Yuge Yugeen Bharat", yaklaşık 340 milyon dolarlık devasa bütçesiyle dikkat çekiyor. Türkçeye "Çağlar Boyunca Hindistan" olarak çevrilebilen müze, ismini ülkenin antik Sanskritçe adı olan Bharat’tan alıyor. İNGİLİZ SÖMÜRGE MİMARİSİ, KADİM HİNT TARİHİNE EV SAHİPLİĞİ YAPACAK AFP'nin haberine göre ilk kez 2023 yılında duyurulan proje, Başbakan Narendra Modi hükümetinin sömürge öncesi kültürel kimliği öne çıkarma vizyonunun en önemli halkalarından biri olarak görülüyor. Müzenin adresi ise oldukça manidar: Başkent Yeni Delhi’de, 1920’li yıllarda İngiliz mimarlar Edwin Lutyens ve Herbert Baker tarafından tasarlanan ve uzun yıllar bürokrasinin kalbi olan eski sivil hizmet binaları (Kuzey ve Güney Blokları). İngiliz sömürge döneminin sembolü olan bu tarihi binalar, artık Hint medeniyetinin ihtişamını sergileyecek. 10 MİLYON ZİYARETÇİ KAPASİTESİ Kabine tarafından yapılan açıklamada müzenin teknik detaylarına ve hedeflerine ilişkin detaylar paylaşıldı.Toplamda yaklaşık 178.509 metrekarelik inşaat alanına sahip olacak müze, küresel ölçekteki tüm rakiplerini geride bırakarak dünyanın en geniş sergileme alanına sahip müzesi konumuna yerleşecek. Ulusal ve eyalet müzelerinden, arkeolojik koleksiyonlardan ve özel arşivlerden derlenen yaklaşık 1,8 milyon tarihi eser, müzede sergilenmek üzere değerlendirmeye alındı. Projenin yılda 10 milyon ziyaretçiyi ağırlayabilecek kapasitede tasarlandığı belirtildi. İLK GALERİ 2027’DE AÇILIYOR Hint medeniyetinin kesintisiz sürekliliğini, çeşitliliğini ve zenginliğini gözler önüne sermeyi hedefleyen dev projenin ilk galerisi 2027 yılının sonunda kapılarını ziyaretçilere açacak. Projenin tamamının ise 2030-2031 mali yılında bitirilmesi planlanıyor. 2014 yılında göreve gelmesinden bu yana ülke mirasını ve kültürünü ön plana çıkaran adımlarıyla tanınan Başbakan Modi, daha önce de 182 metrelik boyuyla dünyanın en yüksek heykeli olan *"Birlik Heykeli"*ni inşa ettirmiş ve 2023 yılında ülkeye yeni bir parlamento binası kazandırmıştı. Anne ve kızına saldırmışlardı: Ülkede 4 boz ayı itlaf edildi! Salgın riskine karşı önlemler artıyor: Ülkede kümes hayvanlarına yeni karar
Israel set to expel 6 detained Italians Saturday says Farnesina
(ANSA) - ROME, 06 NOV - Israel is set to expel six detained Italians on Saturday, the third and latest group of Italians to have been detained while helping Palestinians evade settler violence and pick olives in the West Bank, the Italian foreign ministry, the Farnesina, said Friday. The Farnesina said it is working to secure the release of several Italian activists detained Friday by Israeli authorities near the village of Kafr Ni'ma, in the West Bank. The detention reportedly involves a number of international volunteers, including 4 Italian activists and 2 Italian journalists; final verification of the exact number and identities of the Italians is still underway. The group of activists is currently being held at the Modi'in Illit police station. They are scheduled to be transferred Saturday to a facility at Ben Gurion Airport, ahead of expulsion procedures, which will be carried out on the first available flights. (ANSA). Read article...
Indian Christians warn of attacks in West Bengal
Indian Christian leaders say they suffered systematic attacks on their faith after a spate of church vandalism and assaults in West Bengal state, they told AFP on Friday. Churches have been vandalised and pastors assaulted in the Hindu-majority state of 100 million people since Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s Hindu-nationalist Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) won state elections in May. Hundreds of Christians marched through the state capital Kolkata on Thursday. “For the last five months, we’ve seen systematic attacks being organised against Christians, and the pretext is unlawful conversions,” Herod Mullick of the Bangiya Christiya Pariseba (BCP), which organised the march, told AFP. Christian groups have been accused of trying to convert Hindus to Christianity. Christians account for less than one per cent of West Bengal’s population, according to the last national census. Mullick’s BCP said it had documented 48 instances of “vandalism and atrocities targeting prayer meetings, worship centres and churches” over the past five months, calling it “an unprecedented crisis”. AFP could not independently verify that figure, but other Christian organisations and research groups have also reported alleged attacks. The ruling BJP has rejected the allegations. A state minister has said freedom of worship must be protected, but that complaints of forced conversions would be investigated. The Catholic Association of the Archdiocese of Delhi said in a statement it was “deeply shaken by… the terror being inflicted upon innocent Christians in West Bengal”. The All India Catholic Union condemned a mob attack on a Bible conference in West Bengal’s Nadia district on October 9, when around 200 people stormed a church, smashing decorations and injuring at least six people. The Washington-based India Hate Lab research group said in a September report that it had documented 60 incidents targeting Christians in West Bengal after the BJP took power, including assaults, vandalism and raids on prayer meetings. Mullick said he was seeking a meeting with the chief of the Hindu nationalist RSS, or the Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh (RSS), the ideological fountainhead of the BJP. The RSS and BJP have long accused Christians of forcibly converting Hindus, allegations the community vehemently denies. India has 1.4 billion people and more than two per cent are Christians, according to the last census. Christians say their religion has been present in India for nearly two millennia.
X says police order demanding removal of Indian free-speech groups' accounts was fake
Police orders asking X (formerly known as Twitter) to block online accounts of two of India’s most prominent free speech groups were fake, the social media company told an Indian court on Friday, days after the purported content removal requests sparked a public outcry. The orders, submitted through X’s online reporting form in the name of a senior Delhi police officer, sought the removal of the accounts of the Internet Freedom Foundation (IFF) and the Software Freedom Law Centre, India (SCLC), claiming they had defamed the Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh (RSS), the Hindu nationalist group from which Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s Bharatiya Janata Party emerged. “It turns out this was somebody playing an impostor, somebody impersonating Delhi police who has sent this,” a lawyer for X told the Delhi High Court, saying the company had conducted an internal investigation. Delhi police did not immediately respond to a request for comment. Free-speech activists have repeatedly said that India’s strict content removal regulations are a way to curb dissent in the world’s most populous nation. India, which has more than 1.1 billion internet subscribers, says the directives target unlawful or misleading content and respect lawful expression. The purported takedown orders invoked Indian rules that require platforms to act on the notices within three hours. X forwarded them to the affected users before establishing that they were fake. IFF had asked the court to quash the orders, which sparked an uproar on social media this week, with Amnesty and India’s main opposition party contesting their legality. The groups also received legal notices last week, purportedly on behalf of the RSS, that demanded they stop criticising and documenting government blocking orders, according to the petition.
Is Rahul Gandhi ambitious?
MILLIONS of Indians evidently see Rahul Gandhi as their candidate to steer the country out of its deep mess driven by hate-filled divisive politics and a K-shaped economic trajectory plying unprecedented inequality. That seemed to be the unspoken sentiment, if not consensus, at the massive Sunday rally of opposition parties in Delhi against vote theft. The issue has brought out angry youth on the streets. Rigging of polls betrays, however, an inability to secure popular support through clean elections, which is a blessing. India is not alone in subverting democracy. Narendra Modi’s ride-or-die friendship with Benjamin Netanyahu reveals a shared scorn for secular democracy and minority rights. Netanyahu hopes to disenfranchise Palestinian MPs (strategically called Arabs by a clever political fiat) even as they mock him in turn by holding the balance of power, principally against him, after last week’s elections. Likewise with Modi, whose controversial victories in Bihar and West Bengal recently benefited enormously as his handpicked election commission disenfranchised millions of Muslim voters and other potential opponents of the regime. Netanyahu rewarded Modi’s friendship by giving his government the Pegasus spyware among other contraptions to undermine democracy. One would readily go along with the view that Gandhi makes for a great candidate to don the mantle of prime minister and also restore its prestige. He has displayed the drive to nurse Indian democracy back to health. But is he as equipped as, say, streetfighters like Priyank Kharge or M.K. Stalin or Akhilesh Yadav to deal frontally with the push which will inevitably arrive in the process of dismantling entrenched fascism? That Sonia Gandhi and both her children — Rahul as the leader of the opposition in the Lok Sabha, Priyanka Gandhi as an outspoken and gritty parliamentarian — called out Israel’s genocide in Gaza, while major parties other than the left looked away is cause to celebrate the family — and also something to worry about as it puts them in the crosshairs of many a foreign and domestic interloper. The fact that the RSS chief hosted an Israeli diplomat as chief guest at the Hindutva body’s annual day on Dussehra is troubling. Has anyone bothered to ask Rahul Gandhi if he was himself interested in the job that so many appear keen to award him? A pivotal question needs to be flagged here about widespread faux expertise over a future prime minister from the opposition. Has anyone bothered to ask Rahul Gandhi if he was himself interested in the job that so many appear keen to award him? A fair guess based on history and Nehru-Gandhi genealogy is that Rahul Gandhi harbours no such ambitions. We could perhaps glean the truth of this hunch from Sonia Gandhi’s soon-to-be released memoirs. The BJP routinely accuses Jawaharlal Nehru and his daughter of political ambition. No Indian prime minister with a clear majority in parliament has offered to resign other than Nehru. In February 1950, Nehru offered to resign as prime minister over the refugee crisis after Partition. Sardar Patel persuaded him to withdraw the offer. Again, in 1958, Nehru announced his desire to step down and take a break from office, citing severe mental fatigue, fading idealism, and deteriorating public standards in Indian politics. A public outcry broke out, and the Congress begged him to stay on. Did Nehru want his daughter to succeed him? On the contrary, there’s plenty of evidence that he desired young socialist leader Jai Prakash Narayan as his deputy in 1952, which JP refused. There was not even a remote hint that he wanted his daughter in his cabinet or to succeed him. Nehru was wary of Morarji Desai from the right-wing of the party. He engineered a plan for senior cabinet ministers to resign to work at the grassroots with the party. He inducted Lal Bahadur Shastri as a minister without portfolio in the prime minister’s office, a clear signal who he was tapping as successor. Shastri’s demise in Tashkent set off another round of worry about Desai manoeuvring. Powerful regional satraps countered the move and promoted Indira Gandhi believing she could be manipulated. Mrs Gandhi favoured supporting Gulzari Lal Nanda. The ‘Syndicate’ supporting her was essentially conservative, pro-business, and staunchly anti-socialist. Mrs Gandhi turned the tables on them in 1969 by staging a split with the support of the communist bloc. When the left abandoned her after the emergency — one of their defining errors — she was swamped by the conservatives including religious revivalists who were largely seen as devising her fateful Punjab policy that would eventually lay her low. Rajiv Gandhi was a scrupulously private family man until Sanjay Gandhi’s death in a plane crash required him to stand with his mother. Her assassination set him up as prime minister. There’s no dearth of recorded evidence of Sonia Gandhi opposing his entry into politics. In an emotional showdown, she forbade him from becoming prime minister, presciently fearing he, too, would be killed. Rajiv’s response was: “I am her son … if I don’t do it, who will?” Ambition? Did Sonia Gandhi try to be prime minister in 1999 when she met the president with a list of 272 supporters? The world knows that she backed Manmohan Singh as prime minister in 2004. But a 2014 book by R.D. Pradhan, a civil servant close to Rajiv and Sonia Gandhi, described how Sonia Gandhi had Manmohan Singh in mind as early as 1999. On her part, Sonia Gandhi did one better. She set up a very effective advisory council to informally but crucially advise the Singh government on progressive issues ranging from poverty alleviation, right to information, right to education, halting disinvestment in public sector undertakings — everything that Nehru and Indira Gandhi would approve of. Rahul Gandhi would in all likelihood follow the precepts. His politically correct upbringing could struggle against the ugliness of right-wing politics that prompted Nehru to offer to resign. There are many more roughly hewn leaders in the progressive pack to confront an ugly pushback that would come from a cornered fascist order. The writer is Dawn’s correspondent in Delhi. jawednaqvi@gmail.com Published in Dawn, November 3rd, 2026
Is Rahul Gandhi ambitious?Thousands join Indian opposition protest
India’s opposition parties staged major protests in New Delhi on Sunday against Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s government and a nationwide voter list review that has fuelled demonstrations since the summer, led by the youth movement Cockroach Janta Party. Eliza Herbert reports.
Tens of thousands protest against Narendra Modi regime in Delhi
Led by Congress party, India’s opposition alliance channels anger over removal of 130 million names from voter roll Thousands of opposition supporters have gathered in Delhi as protests against the Narendra Modi government continue to gather momentum. Led by the Congress party, India’s opposition alliance has brought together supporters from across the country, amid growing anger over a large-scale revision of the country’s voter roll that has seen 130 million names erased. Continue reading...
Thousands protest in India's capital against voter roll revision
Thousands joined a protest led by opposition politicians in India’s capital on Sunday, renewing demands for the country’s election chief to resign over an overhaul of voter lists they say unfairly benefits the ruling party. The nationwide revision of electoral rolls has sparked political disputes and street protests in the world’s largest democracy over the last month. The Election Commission says the initiative is necessary to ensure accurate voter lists, but the opposition claims it is being manipulated to favour Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP). Both the Election Commission and the BJP deny the accusations. On Sunday, protesters led by opposition Congress party leader Rahul Gandhi chanted “vote thief, leave your seat” and beat drums while marching from central parts of New Delhi to Ramlila Maidan, a large outdoor venue. “I have been a voter since I was 18 and now I find myself struck off the list,” protester Nandita, 46, told AFP, giving only one name. “It’s important to be here because of the way things are going. The cost of living is going up… The only option is to take to the streets peacefully.” The Cockroach Janta Party (CJP), an online youth-led protest movement, has also thrown its weight behind the campaign against the voter-roll revision. The overhaul of India’s voter rolls has resulted in more than 133 million names being removed from electoral lists, according to figures reported by Indian media and cited by opposition parties in court filings. Critics say the removals have disproportionately affected minorities, particularly Muslims. Members of Hindu-nationalist BJP have long alleged that large numbers of undocumented Muslim migrants from neighbouring Bangladesh have fraudulently entered India’s electoral rolls. Election authorities say the revision was intended to eliminate duplicate, deceased and fraudulent entries, and that eligible voters remain entitled to apply for inclusion on the roll. Human Rights Watch has said the removal of voters was “arbitrary and deeply flawed”. “The authorities should immediately scrap the voter roll revision process that has denied India’s most marginalised people their right to vote and other government services,” it said in a statement this week. The Cockroach movement has been heavily involved in the pushback to the voter-roll revision and several of its leaders were temporarily detained by police during protests last month. The CJP has gained millions of followers on social media since it was launched in May. Earlier protests organised by the CJP in July over exam irregularities forced the resignation of the education minister, marking a rare climbdown by Modi’s administration.
Nuclear jingoism
INDIA’S nuclear jingoism was on ample display during Operation Marka-i-Haq in May 2025 when it fired dual-use BrahMos cruise missiles with conventional payload, unmindful of the fact that the dangerous caper could have been misconstrued by Pakistani air defenders as a nuclear attack. Despite an agreement on pre-notification of flight testing of ballistic missiles, the Indians, while testing the Agni V MIRV-capable missile, have shown a blithe disregard for established pre-notification protocols that mandate a 72-hour pre-test notification, a fact pointed out by Pakistan’s Foreign Office in 2024. While the Indians keep up an implacable momentum of vertical proliferation of nuclear and missile technology, the world indulges them through exceptionalism enshrined in the nuclear waiver for the Nuclear Suppliers Group and membership of the Missile Technology Control Regime. The Indians have slyly wangled the concession from the USA and IAEA in the civil nuclear deal to keep eight reactors out of IAEA oversight. These pressurised heavy water reactors consume less nuclear fuel than they produce, which can be harvested for strategic military purposes. It should be remembered that it was the Indians who introduced the nuclear arms race in the subcontinent because of their grandiose big-power pretensions. Their nuclear explosions in 1974 and 1998 forced Pakistan to follow suit out of its security compulsions. The world indulges India through nuclear exceptionalism. The Indian nuclear security architecture was provided conceptual ballast by Gen K. Sunderji and Krishna Subramanyam in the 1980s, when they came up with the notion of no-first use of nuclear weapons against a non-nuclear nation, with a caveat of making an exception for biological and chemical attacks. However, India kept developing its conventional forces, especially the armoured and mechanised component, as per the Sunderji doctrine, aimed at tearing Pakistan asunder. On the geopolitical level the Indians have acquiesced to the status of a regional surrogate to accommodate balancing needs of the US vis-a-vis a rising global competitor, China. While enjoying nuclear exceptionalism the Indians went on a shopping spree for nuclear technology as well as the conventional hardware to operationalise the military strategy that sought an elusive space for conventional wars under the nuclear overhang. The operational manifestation of these military ambitions was a slew of concepts starting with Cold Start and graduating to proactive operations. The latest manifestation of those concepts is the Dynamic Response Strategy that is based on rapidly deployable all-arms-based integrated battle groups and multidomain-enabled terrain-customised brigade-sized groups called Rudra Brigades. Pakistan relies on its full-spectrum deterrence, keeping strategic nuclear ambiguity for greater liberty of action to deny India the space for conventional conflict. While India deploys non-state actors to keep Pakistan destabilised through terrorism, it cleverly conflates Pakistan’s principled support to the victims of Indian state repression in Occupied Kashmir, a UNSC-recognised dispute, with militancy. It has also withdrawn from its international law commitments by illegally holding the Indus Waters Treaty in abeyance and imperilling the food security of Pakistan. India under the BJP and RSS sway has adopted a foreign policy based upon the antiquated notion of ‘Akhand Bharat’ that covets the territories of neighbours based on historical myths. The inflammatory statement of Prime Minister Narendra Modi at Barmer, Rajasthan, during an election rally that “Indian nukes are not kept for Diwali” indicates a bellicose mindset. It is against the backdrop of the above facts that the notions of nuclear deterrence in the subcontinent have to be understood. Since the stability of nuclear deterrence is based upon nuclear dialectics between two rational actors, Indian irrationality adds dangerous instability to the nuclear equation. The deployment of canisterised ground-based ready-to-use nuclear missiles and the submarine-launched nuclear ballistic missiles point to an aggressive nuclear intent when viewed in the context of Indo-Pak distrust and irrationality of the ideologically driven BJP leadership. The well-known military historian Martin Van Creveld had coined a term for wars in the nuclear era: “Non-trinitarian”, where, unlike Clausewitz’s trinitarian wars, the only political objective would be deterring and not winning the wars. Whether India has strengthened or reduced its strategic deterrence by fielding shallow-range submarine-based missiles is a point to ponder by Indian nuclear strategists. The writer is a PhD from NUST. rwjanj@hotmail.com Published in Dawn, October 30th, 2026
Nuclear jingoism"Dreadful Wars Should End": EU Foreign Affairs Chief Backs PM Modi's Peace Push
David McAllister, Chair of the European Parliament's Foreign Affairs Committee, said India "is one of the players who might be able to navigate and negotiate between Moscow and Kyiv."
Poland pivots towards India as ‘strategic partnership’ with China develops cracks
Poland and India seek to raise bilateral trade from $6 bn to $10 bn; PM Modi visited Poland in 2024, during which ties were elevated to ‘strategic partnership’; Warsaw is also trying to diversify partnerships as trade imbalance and Beijing’s support for Russia deepen disillusionment with China
What Marco Rubio’s sidestepping of New Delhi says about the US’s stance on India
Rubio’s decision not to meet Narendra Modi last week was seen by some as a snub – but by focusing on business leaders and oil, the secretary of state made American priorities clear. Plus: the artist bringing a female perspective to men’s clothing • Don’t get This is India delivered to your inbox? Sign up here When the US secretary of state, Marco Rubio, visited India for the second time this year, headlines concentrated on who he met and where he went. The fact that Rubio bypassed New Delhi and did not meet the prime minister, Narendra Modi, during his trip last week, and instead traveled to the financial capital, Mumbai, where he met India’s foreign minister, Subrahmanyam Jaishankar (pictured top with Rubio), and business leaders, did not go unnoticed. Nor did his decision to travel to Jamnagar, the small Gujarati town that is home to Reliance Industries’ colossal oil refinery complex. Continue reading...
In a pickle in Jamnagar
THE massive Reliance refinery in Jamnagar abutting the Arabian Sea from its perch in Gujarat was inaugurated in December 1999. There may be absolutely no connection between the refinery’s birthday and India’s nuclear tests of May 1998. But it’s difficult also to ignore the high stakes involved in its presence facing Pakistan, which too became a nuclear power that year. History shows a pattern of power play associated with such critical and strategic assets. It was on the eve of World War I that Churchill decided that the Royal Navy should switch to oil and away from Welsh coal to make the fleet faster and more efficient. But with no oil of its own, Britain turned to the Abadan refinery, which would eventually become the world’s largest such facility, except that it was needlessly close to the border with Iraq. The refinery was at the heart of the 1953 coup against Mohammad Mossadegh when the elected prime minister nationalised the oil industry. It was the first scalp for Saddam Hussein in the long war he launched against Iran in 1980. The Jamnagar refinery is said to be the world’s largest facility to process the most difficult of crude oils, including hugely discounted volumes imported from cash-strapped Venezuela. Given its proximity to Pakistan, the facility has figured in comments by analysts and voluble generals alike as a potential target, a veritable sitting duck. The Ambani family on its part has played an active role in seeking to improve ties with Pakistan. They reportedly played a role in pleading through a former US president close to the family in pressing Gen Pervez Musharraf to allow Nawaz Sharif to be able to leave Pakistan to live in exile. The refinery has also featured as a potential bridge between the implacable rivals, at one point offering to transport refined products to Pakistan through the Punjab border. Given the fact that India has only suspended the war it launched against Pakistan under the sobriquet of Operation Sindoor and not brought it to a closure, the tense ties are expected to continue to keep a range of targets in the crosshairs of both sides. In the prevailing circumstances of a global economic meltdown mocking the poor and the rich alike, it’s probably just a question of a nudge that the proverbial ice is broken between the two, and last week may have offered a sliver of such a hope. The day US Secretary of State Marco Rubio came to visit the Reliance oil refinery in Jamnagar, President Mohamed Muizzu of the Maldives was landing in Islamabad where he would give an unusual call to revive the frozen South Asian Association for Regional Cooperation (Saarc). Muizzu’s call had a strange ring to it given that he was elected to lead his archipelago nation in 2023 on the openly anti-India slogan of “India out”. The US wants to dry up Moscow’s wartime oil revenues by pushing India toward alternative heavy crude markets. Seen as close to Beijing and pointedly hostile to New Delhi at the time, Muizzu preferred a mellow approach in Pakistan when Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif broached the two issues he routinely raises: Kashmir and Indus water sharing with India. Leading the first Maldivian state visit to Islamabad in 11 years, Muizzu kept his sights on sweeping maritime security and defence pacts. For both Pakistan and the Maldives, a stronger bilateral relationship is seen as serving as a necessary strategic counterweight to balance India’s regional dominance. Rubio’s visit to Jamnagar was not only aimed at sending more stolen oil from Venezuela for refining with a view to easing the enormous pressure put by the reckless Israel-US war on Iran on global fuel markets. Rubio’s primary objective apparently was to convince Reliance to buy more Venezuelan crude while aggressively cutting its intake of Russian oil. Following Western sanctions on Russia, India became Russia’s top oil buyer. The US wants to dry up Moscow’s wartime oil revenues by pushing India toward alternative heavy crude markets. Gleaning from Rubio’s description, the US sees Jamnagar as the only facility globally with the sheer muscle to offset Russian volumes. Before the visit ended, however, unflattering news came trickling in from Arunachal Pradesh, an Indian-ruled province China claims as South Tibet. The paramilitary patrol keeping vigil for India had had recent face-offs with Chinese counterparts at several parts of the border where they had held their ground valiantly. Or so claimed the paramilitary chief Shatrujeet Kapur. His comments were said to have been taken down and the government denied anything at all was really amiss. Only a couple of days or so before the reported transgressions around Arunachal Pradesh and their denial by New Delhi, the two countries had gone through a notably high-decibel exchange over the naming of geographical features in Ladakh. The Global Times, considered close to China’s ruling Communist Party, wrote a long editorial reminding India of the need to avoid disturbing the agreement on peace and tranquillity along their border. A bird’s-eye view of the South Asia chessboard, therefore, reveals a fraught cross-section of forces at play. Pakistan appears agreeable in its ties with the three big powers — the US, China and Russia. Whereas India has struggled to keep the US in good humour, which makes it even more of an ordeal to avoid annoying Russia, a traditional ally in countless ways. With China, the relations require a greater quotient of tender care but with scant quantities in sight. Add to the mix the Indian youth mobilisation that’s rocked the over 12-year-old government of Prime Minister Narendra Modi. Has Rubio created more trouble for Modi, including by not even meeting him during the visit, or has he by visiting Jamnagar set the grounds for a diplomatic entente with neighbours? Which would leave Modi elbowroom to address the domestic crisis with any degree of composure or hope to endure the pickle he is in. The writer is Dawn’s correspondent in Delhi. jawednaqvi@gmail.com Published in Dawn, October 27th, 2026
In a pickle in JamnagarSeason of protests
A WAVE of protests is sweeping across the world in a season of unrest. From West to East, the street is confronting the state. Led predominantly by students and young people, protests have been widening to encompass other disaffected groups in society. In some cases, they are morphing into a nationwide movement. On almost every continent, governments are being put on notice that there will be a price to pay for misgovernance and being indifferent to public demands. India’s Gen Z has been in the streets in anti-government protests against the controversial revision of electoral rolls. Students in France began protesting against deteriorating school conditions with other groups, including trade unions, joining demonstrations over high living costs and inequality. In Italy, students, farmers and truckers took to the streets in protests driven by education costs, economic grievances, and anti-war sentiment. In Brussels, students marched over education funding. Spain saw protests over a housing crisis. In Albania, student-led demonstrations occurred over living costs and a controversial tourism project linked to Jared Kushner, President Donald Trump’s son-in-law. In Portugal, protests erupted over housing and falling living standards. There were education protests across Greece. In Brazil, thousands joined a student march against the election bid of far-right candidate Flávio Bolsonaro. Tunisia’s capital witnessed protests demanding the president’s resignation and democratic rights. The triggers vary, as do the underlying causes. Each protest is rooted in its own political context. But there are common themes. All reject the status quo and indicate disenchantment with traditional political parties. All voice anger against unresponsive governments and the state failing them on their socioeconomic demands. The context for most protests is a cost-of-living crisis and deterioration or cuts in public services compounded by the state’s inability to deliver on education and jobs. Economic grievances and resentment of inequality are a driving force of the protests. A sense of disenfranchisement is another common thread. The heavy-handed response by governments to the protests and draconian crackdowns further fuelled the unrest and sparked violent clashes in several places. But it energised demonstrators to keep returning to the street. Unfortunately, in France protests degenerated into looting and rioting. Protests in Europe and India share a defining feature. They are propelled by a wave of student activism. At their core is youth frustration in a generation that sees broken promises and an uncertain future. It feels betrayed by the lack of educational and economic opportunities. Protesters have also been venting rage against political leaders who have ignored public needs and are seen as venal. Initiated by young people, protests have expanded into broader movements as other disaffected groups, with their own set of demands, joined the demonstrations. Social media has been a key mobilisation tool in all the protests. Governments have been put on notice that misrule and ignoring public needs will have consequences. None of the protests or movements have been party-led. Political parties have largely been sidelined, even as they tried to leverage the demonstrations; France’s left aligned itself with the protesters. In several European countries, protests are playing out in an environment of deep polarisation, which parties of both the left and right are trying to exploit. This is especially because elections are due next year in many countries including France, Spain, and Italy. In India, the youth ‘Cockroach’ movement has spearheaded the protests and mounted the most significant challenge to Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s government so far. The ongoing protests came against the backdrop of student protests led by the Cockroach party over the leak of exam papers in May, which forced the resignation of the education minister. This time, the catalyst was the revision of voter lists by India’s election commission, which apparently involved the removal of around 130 million voters. The government and the election commission’s claim that this was aimed at eliminating duplicate and ineligible entries was widely rejected. It was instead seen as a step towards mass disenfranchisement. It became the trigger for youth protests, demanding the resignation of the chief election commissioner and scrapping the revision. India’s opposition parties also joined the demonstrations and decried the move as a politically motivated purge to benefit the ruling BJP. The Cockroach Janta Party used the opportunity to broaden its campaign. The government’s strong-arm tactics to suppress the popular upsurge only inflamed the demonstrators who accused Modi of “stealing democracy”. While these protests did not pose an existential threat to Modi, his jittery and increasingly autocratic government behaved as if they did — with arrests and a harsh clampdown. The scale of the protests and the government’s repressive response eroded Modi’s authority, weakened his grip on power, and dented his credibility and image. The mass protests signified much more than opposition to the voter roll overhaul. They have been about democratic rights and democratic accountability and against pervasive injustice. As Indian academic Sudhir Kumar Suthar has argued, they have been driven by the quest for dignity as much as for rights. The message from the young is clear: “they deserve a more dignified life than what they have received from the system so far.” The central question is what will be the outcome of mass protests and what will they achieve? A definitive assessment has to wait until the protests play themselves out as most are still unfolding. But one unintended consequence of the current wave of discontent in some European countries, especially France but to a degree also in Spain and Portugal, may be to strengthen the far-right. The far-right has led none of these protests but it stands to benefit from their fallout. In a political landscape where the political centre is being hollowed out and centrist parties have lost touch with young people, unrest advantages the most organised opposition force that promises order. In France, that force is Marine Le Pen’s Rassemblement National. Where the hard-right is in power the advantage works differently. It enables governments to cast the protests as a law-and-order issue fuelled by migrants to justify harsher measures. More generally, youth-led protests may force governments to take more seriously the needs and aspirations of young people which have rarely been a priority. What the streets are signalling is a breakdown of trust that can no longer be brushed aside. For now, the protests have put governments on notice: misrule has consequences. The writer is a former ambassador to the US, UK and UN. Published in Dawn, October 26th, 2026
The nuclear danger at sea
Dawn’s October 23 editorial rightly warned about India’s nuclear-armed submarine patrols. The danger is larger than a new vessel at sea. It is a sea-based nuclear force growing alongside precision-strike capabilities, missile defence and a false confidence in initiating military action. Imagining that these developments confer a first-strike advantage or create a safe space for war is imprudent. Pakistan has the capability and resolve to preserve the strategic balance. Retired Lt-Gen Mazhar Jamil, Adviser to the National Command Authority, warned at the International Institute for Strategic Studies on October 13 that continuous at-sea deterrence further weakens the credibility of India’s declared no-first-use policy and points towards an offensive strike posture. He added that unannounced submarine-launched ballistic-missile tests, with operationalised weapons aboard submarines, raise the risks of misperception and escalation. Pakistan reserves the right to take all appropriate measures to protect its security and the regional balance. At the Islamabad Non-Proliferation Conference a week later, retired Lt-Gen Khalid Kidwai, also an adviser to the National Command Authority, reinforced the warning, saying Pakistan would review its options if India sought to impose a strategic imbalance. In June 2026, the Stockholm International Peace Research Institute (Sipri) estimated that India had a stockpile of 190 nuclear warheads and 12 of these deployed on a nuclear-powered ballistic-missile submarine for occasional deterrence patrols. That estimate is too low and arrives seven years late. Prime Minister Modi announced the INS Arihant’s first deterrence patrol in 2018 and the Indian Navy again patrolled it again during the 2019 crisis. India has three operational ballistic-missile submarines (SBBN), with a fourth expected in 2027. Next year, the four SSBNs will have a combined capacity to launch missiles carrying up to 72 warheads from 24 tubes. A larger fleet of 12 nuclear ballistic and attack submarines is envisaged in the 2030s. Aggressive posturing India’s professed no-first-use pledge cannot be judged without taking into account its capabilities and political conduct. A ready, concealed launch platform gains a different meaning when combined with counterforce ambitions, missile defence and talk of pre-emption. General Kidwai’s assessment about a possible strike at ‘zero notice’ should be read in that setting. Pakistan has never allowed its deterrence capability to be neutralised by India’s posture that is taken as routine modernisation. Strategic stability rests on a credible balance and Pakistan will maintain it under all circumstances. General Zubair Hayat, former Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff Committee, argued at the Islamabad Non-proliferation Conference that the old international order is giving way without an equitable replacement. His strategic point applies here: strategic exemptions for a favoured state, followed by alarm at its neighbour’s balancing measures, do not produce equal security. The nuclearisation of the Indian Ocean did not begin when Pakistan raised its concerns. It began with India’s risky choices, enabled and fuelled by an international tendency to treat its ambitions as benign. May 2025 demonstrated the danger of that assumption on land and in the air. On the first anniversary of Marka-i-Haq, President Asif Ali Zardari reiterated that India used Pahalgam’s false flag as a guise for premeditated strikes. India ignored Pakistan’s offer of a neutral investigation and had to endure a defeat and loss of face. Pakistan’s calibrated conventional response, under political authority, restored conventional deterrence, while Full Spectrum Deterrence preserved the strategic ceiling. The Indian Air Force grounded itself, and the Indian Navy’s carrier strike group cut a hasty retreat to safety. The ceasefire followed Islamabad’s response and New Delhi’s call for third-party mediation. There was no safe band of war then, and there is none at sea now. A lesson for India Retired Lt-Gen Sarfraz Sattar, who served as Director General of the Strategic Plans Division, has also warned that emerging technologies and great-power competition threaten nuclear stability. The March 2022 BrahMos launch into Pakistan showed why. A supersonic nuclear-capable missile crossed the border in peacetime; India waited nearly two days before acknowledging it and did not accept Pakistan’s call for a joint inquiry and preserved the risk of escalation. Three years on, India carried that risk into wartime by employing BrahMos against another nuclear power — the first such instance. The sea-leg of India’s nuclear triad and dual-capable missiles are sinews of a Hindutva-inflected policy of hegemony and coercion. Pakistan’s declared Full Spectrum Deterrence covers the range of threats it faces, and it clearly signals that aggression at any level or in any domain risks a response that will deny objectives and impose costs; an adversary cannot dictate the level at which a confrontation will remain. Political authority, prepared forces and credible options give that warning its weight. As India’s posture changes, Pakistan will take the measures necessary to safeguard its sovereignty and strategic balance. Risk reduction has value, but it cannot substitute for deterrence or responsible political choices. Dialogue is worthwhile when it reduces the incentives and opportunities for unilateral force, not when it is offered as a substitute for Pakistan’s defence. Pakistan always stands ready to impose greater costs for on any misadventure that India may undertake, including the maritime domain. In May 2025, Islamabad demonstrated that its calibrated notch-up response should not be read to mean that every aggression will meet the same ceiling. General Kidwai also recommended adding a “plus” to Pakistan’s quid-pro-quo plus response strategy. The lesson for India is direct. Neither an expanding submarine fleet nor other developments give it an edge over Pakistan’s response to aggression. Pakistan has demonstrated both resolve and the means to defend itself. It will preserve the balance on which peace depends. In the Subcontinent, the true enemy is the delusion that war can be kept safely on a lower rung. That Indian aspiration makes the unthinkable look controllable. It’s an illusion that a war can be started low, kept low, and stopped on command. A political choice driven by Hindutva and Akhand Bharat may begin the escalation; interaction decides where it goes. Field Marshal Asim Munir expressed the governing reality most aptly: there is no space for war in a nuclearised environment.
Nuclear uncertainty'Trade, Technology, Sea Routes Being Weaponised': PM Modi At NDTV World Summit On Changing Global Order
Prime Minister Narendra Modi, speaking at the NDTV World Summit 2026, asserted that the global order is changing, but international institutions such as the United Nations are struggling to keep pace.
Fear as Indians struggle to prove voting rights
Laddli Khatun pulled one document after another from a yellow bag, desperately hoping one would be enough to keep her name on India’s electoral rolls. As the world’s largest democracy overhauls its voter lists, millions like Khatun are scrambling to re-establish their credentials, despite having voted before. Critics and opposition parties say the exercise risks mass disenfranchisement, and those removed fear wider citizenship repercussions. A woman leaves after submitting documents to register for the Draft Electoral Roll 2026 as part of the Election Commission of India’s Special Intensive Revision (SIR), at a voter verification camp in New Delhi on October 18, 2026. —AFP More than 133 million names — including 28 million listed as dead — have been cut from rolls, according to figures reported by Indian media and cited by opposition parties in court filings. Protests have rocked New Delhi, with demonstrators demanding the chief election commissioner’s resignation, alleging the overhaul is designed to benefit Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP). The Election Commission of India (ECI), a constitutional body, denies wrongdoing and says the revision complies with the law. ‘Burden of proof’ The Special Intensive Revision (SIR) requires voters to link themselves —directly or through their parents or grandparents —to electoral rolls from 2002-03, the last time such a rigorous review took place. Khatun, 39, was not of voting age at the time. So she must now prove that at least one of her parents or grandparents featured on those rolls. “My parents died when I was a baby,” Khatun, who lives in a Delhi slum, told AFP at a hearing reviewing voter credentials. “They were poor unlettered people who left no documents behind.” Many face Khatun’s predicament. Booth level-officer (BLO) Mukesh Khanna (R) assists people to register their documents for the Draft Electoral Roll 2026 as part of the Election Commission of India’s Special Intensive Revision (SIR), at a voter verification camp in New Delhi on October 18, 2026. —AFP “Women, minorities, people living at the margins and the poorest are the worst hit by this exercise, because they find it very difficult to produce documents which can prove their citizenship,” said transparency activist Anjali Bhardwaj. The Election Commission previously sought to enrol eligible voters through door-to-door visits, guided by its motto: “No voter to be left behind”. Critics say the exercise shifts the “burden of proof” onto voters. “The methodology followed has been of physical door-to-door verification,” former election commissioner Ashok Lavasa told AFP. “It was never that you asked people wholesale to establish their eligibility all over again… after they have been admitted to the rolls through the prescribed due process.” ‘Untraceable’ Surajmukhi, made homeless when an eviction drive demolished the slum where she had lived for 30 years, was removed from Delhi’s draft rolls and marked “untraceable”. “I have no document to link myself to the 2002 voter rolls, because at the time I was not enrolled as a voter, and my parents are long dead,” she said, standing in the rubble of her home. “But I have voted multiple times since — the officials themselves came to our home and enrolled us as voters. What has suddenly changed?” Officials on the ground acknowledge the difficulties the exercise poses for poorer voters. “Mapping yourself to the 2002 voter lists is not easy for those who are not educated and technologically savvy,” said Mukesh Khanna, a booth-level officer in a Delhi suburb with a large population of working-class migrants. Special camps have been set up to help voters, but many still struggle to navigate the process. ‘Suspicious’ Millions have also been flagged for additional checks after the Election Commission used automated systems to identify what it calls “logical discrepancies”, including mismatched names and inconsistent family details. Independent analyses suggest Muslims have been disproportionately affected. A man waits with documents to register for the Draft Electoral Roll 2026 as part of the Election Commission of India’s Special Intensive Revision (SIR), at a voter verification camp in New Delhi on October 18, 2026. —AFP In Delhi, an analysis by The Hindu newspaper found Muslims accounted for around 20 per cent of voters flagged, compared with 13.6pc of the electorate. The disparity was even starker in West Bengal, according to the Kolkata-based policy think tank Sabar Institute. Street cleaner Shahida, 42, received a notice because her mother was only 15 years older than her — an age gap the software flagged as “suspicious”. “What am I expected to do — go back in time and ask my dead grandparents why they got my dead mother married so young?” she said. “The reality is child marriages were common among the poor at the time.” National rugby player and actor Aslam, 24, who uses one name, said his voter registration was flagged as “suspicious” because six other people were linked to his deceased father, according to a notice seen by AFP. “It is clearly targeted against voters who don’t vote for the BJP,” said Aslam, a Muslim with six siblings. “It almost feels like the idea is to create a category of second-class citizens.” Modi’s Hindu-nationalist BJP, which strongly backs the revision, has long alleged that undocumented migrants from neighbouring Bangladesh — particularly Muslims — have fraudulently entered electoral rolls. The Supreme Court has said exclusion from electoral rolls does not establish that someone is a foreign national. However, Indian media have reported cases in West Bengal in which people excluded from voter rolls were accused of being undocumented migrants from Bangladesh, detained and, in some instances, pushed across the border. For Khatun, the prospect of such an outcome hangs over an already gruelling ordeal. “I have provided document after document, everything that I have,” she said. But what if they still ask us to leave the country?
Fear as Indians struggle to prove voting rightsSeason of uprisings
PERHAPS the most unfortunate aspect of the latest French popular uprising is that it may well facilitate Marine Le Pen’s journey to the Élysée Palace. The far-right contender for the presidency poses as the law-and-order saviour for a France that no longer exists, focusing — like the Trump regime — on immigration as the source of every societal woe. The unrest that erupted in September with students from a couple of public high schools complaining about shrinking resources and inadequate facilities ballooned into a much broader rebellion. By last weekend, the protests had extended beyond disenchanted pupils and their parents and teachers to a far wider cross-section of society complaining about the cost of living — alongside the usual panoply of vandals, looters, and arsonists. The latter were on the fringes of largely peaceful demonstrations but inevitably grabbed the headlines, featuring images of shattered shopfronts and the historic Limoges town hall in flames. To be fair, though, almost every report I came across acknowledged the carnivalesque aspect of the huge marches, distinguishing it from the criminality of opportunist gangs. Even President Emmanuel Macron made that distinction in his unimpressive address to the nation on Sunday, but offered little more than retribution for the offenders and a dialogue with ‘stakeholders’. Earlier, in response to the students’ demands, the government promised 3,000 more substitute teachers, but that’s not likely to alleviate concerns. With France’s national debt at 119pc of its GDP, the usual excuse is that the state cannot afford to throw money at education (or health), let alone consider social spending that might ease wider cost-of-living woes. Yet economists have worked out that a relatively small increase in inheritance tax for the wealthiest one per cent of heirs would suffice for a substantial investment in education, while Thomas Piketty notes that the growth in private wealth means “France has never been richer”, notwithstanding its public debt. Echoes of 1968 have been discerned in the events in France. That’s a familiar story. In Europe alone, economic woes have prompted mass protests from the Iberian Peninsula to Albania. The rough end of the European housing crisis featured prominently in Spain, where citizens revolted once more after 87-year-old Maricarmen Abascal was forcibly evicted from her home of 70 years because she could not afford the 230pc rent increase. She died a fortnight later, prompting more outrage. A snap election has been called for Nov 29 after the right-wing opposition thwarted two decrees from the Pedro Sánchez government aimed at redressing tenants’ woes. Similar concerns have brought Portuguese citizens to the streets, and broader affordability worries have led to protests in Belgium and Italy. In Albania, meanwhile, the ‘flamingo’ protests that grew from environmental concerns over an island that Donald Trump’s daughter and son-in-law sought to colonise have expanded to include less esoteric concerns, spreading from the capital Tirana to various other cities and demanding the departure of the prime minister and opposition leader. La France Insoumise, the only viable left-wing force in French politics, has backed the agitators and condemned the violence, but should LFI leader Jean-Luc Mélenchon make it into the second round of the next presidential election, there’s little doubt that the extreme centre epitomised by Macron will opt for Le Pen, effectively authorising a second Vichy regime. Similar patterns are likely to be witnessed in the rest of the continent. Happily, the prospects in India differ. There is no scope for complacency, but the Cockroach Janta Party and its allies have clearly rattled the Modi regime. Its demise may not be imminent, but it’s no longer inconceivable. Every country deserves a Neha Bora. Several commentators in Pakistan have lamented the lack of parallels. Sorrow and angst were expressed after 34 pupils and a teacher were killed last week in a roof collapse at a private Peshawar school. In many other countries, such a tragedy would have prompted demands for a nationwide reckoning, not least because of the criminally low state spending on education. But Pakistan, it seems, has better things to do. Echoes of 1968 have been discerned in the events in France. Back then, university students, eventually backed by the unionised working class, briefly chased away Charles de Gaulle. He returned in apparent triumph but was gone within a year. Meanwhile, our first field marshal, hailed by his Western sponsors as Pakistan’s de Gaulle, departed for good after a student-led popular rebellion in 1968-69. It isn’t necessary to condone what followed to hail the demise of the Ayub regime as a tremendous achievement. But perhaps it’s also a reminder to be careful what you wish for, given what followed in the next decade. mahir.dawn@gmail.com Published in Dawn, October 21st, 2026
Season of uprisingsSikh referendum in Canada draws 23,000 votes, expands campaign against Modi
WASHINGTON: More than 23,000 votes were reportedly cast in Edmonton, Canada, on Sunday in a referendum-style exercise organized by Sikhs for Justice (SFJ), which seeks an independent Sikh homeland in India’s Punjab. Voting was extended beyond the scheduled closing time to accommodate people waiting in line, organizers said. Held on Oct 18 at the Alberta Legislature Grounds, the non-binding exercise was part of SFJ’s international campaign for Khalistan, an independent Sikh state. It had no official standing. The more consequential development was SFJ general counsel Gurpatwant Singh Pannun’s announcement of a three-pronged strategy to challenge Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s government: continue overseas referendums, support political and youth movements opposing the government inside India, and press foreign investors to withdraw from Indian markets. Describing the initiative as “Fifth-Generation Warfare,” Pannun declared that “toppling Modi’s regime” was his immediate political objective. “Toppling Modi’s regime is a step forward” in SFJ’s struggle, he said, adding, “Our struggle continues.” Pannun, a US-based lawyer and prominent advocate of Sikh separatism, is a dual US-Canadian citizen. India designated him an individual terrorist in 2020 and has banned SFJ under its anti-terrorism law. He has also been the target of an alleged assassination plot in the United States. In February 2026, Indian national Nikhil Gupta pleaded guilty in a US court to charges connected with a plot to murder a US citizen at the direction of an Indian government employee, according to the US Justice Department. Published in Dawn, October 21st, 2026
Pakistan warns India against attempt to alter strategic balance
ISLAMABAD: Adviser to the National Command Authority retired Lt Gen Khalid Kidwai on Tuesday warned that Pakistan could review its deployment options to restore strategic balance in South Asia, saying India was moving towards a more prepared, potentially first-use capable nuclear posture. “Pakistan never has and never will accept strategic imbalances to be induced in South Asia,” Mr Kidwai said at the second Islamabad Non-Proliferation Conference, hosted by the Strategic Vision Institute, an Islamabad based think tank specialising in strategic issues. “Pakistan will review and reconsider all options for appropriate deployments in order to restore the strategic balance and strategic stability while retaining the policy of strategic ambiguity,” he added. Mr Kidwai and retired Lt Gen Sarfraz Sattar, both former heads of the Strategic Plans Division and advisers to the NCA, said India’s reported deployment of nuclear weapons aboard a submarine, alongside missile modernisation and recent military confrontations, raised the risk of escalation between the two neighbouring arch rivals. NCA adviser reminds India of Pakistan’s Full Spectrum Deterrence policy Nuclear warheads Citing the Stockholm International Peace Research Institute’s SIPRI Yearbook 2026 and other publicly available information, they pointed to reports that India had deployed around 12 nuclear warheads on a submarine for deterrence patrols. They also cited missile canisterisation and wider nuclear and conventional modernisation as developments that cast doubt on India’s declared No-First-Use policy. Mr Kidwai said the reported deployment suggested India had mated nuclear warheads with submarine launched ballistic missiles and begun sea based deterrence patrols. “I do not see any reason as to why an SIPRI report might be inaccurate or speculative,” he said. “This irresponsible escalatory transition towards creating asymmetry in nuclear posture will have profound destabilising effects on South Asian strategic stability,” he added. Mr Kidwai said India’s ability to maintain a continuous at sea deterrent further undermined the credibility of its No-First-Use policy and pointed to a more offensive nuclear posture. “The operational reality that emerges is that India can undertake a first strike against Pakistan at zero notice,” he said. Advance notification He also questioned the absence of advance notification for Indian submarine launched ballistic missile tests, warning that such developments could heighten the risk of miscalculation during a crisis. Referring to the February 2019 confrontation, he said India had reportedly deployed its Arihant nuclear submarine in the Indian Ocean after carrying out air strikes near Balakot in Pakistan, presumably with nuclear weapons aboard. He described the latest reported deployment as part of India’s wider effort to operationalise mated nuclear weapons on submarines. “Pakistan reserves the right to undertake all appropriate measures to safeguard its national security and preserve strategic balance in the region under all circumstances,” Mr Kidwai said. He urged India to understand the implications of Pakistan’s Full Spectrum Deterrence policy. “India in fact will be well advised to read and re-read Pakistan’s policy of Full Spectrum Deterrence and seriously absorb its wide ranging implications for strategic deterrence, strategic stability, and for India’s security,” he said. Mr Sattar said the May 2025 conflict between the nuclear-armed neighbours showed how quickly conventional hostilities could escalate. The ceasefire came after both sides used cruise and ballistic missiles and India deployed strategic naval assets, he said. He drew parallels with the 2019 confrontation, when Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi referred to the deployment of nuclear submarines for deterrence patrols and the positioning of BrahMos missiles along Pakistan’s border. The May 2025 fighting was more intense, involving kamikaze drones, supersonic BrahMos missiles capable of carrying conventional or nuclear warheads, and cyber and electronic warfare, he said. “It is now clear that the 2025 conflict was much more lethal in comparison to the 2019 conflict,” Mr Sattar said, warning that the fighting risked spiralling towards nuclear escalation through accident or miscalculation. He cited India’s canisterisation of land and sea based missiles, pursuit of multiple independently targetable reentry vehicle (MIRV) capabilities, short-range tactical missiles, ballistic missile defences, hypersonic weapons and autonomous platforms as further sources of concern. Combined with India’s Cold Start doctrine, wider military modernisation and the absence of a bilateral arms control mechanism, these developments raised doubts about its No-First-Use declaration and traditionally recessed deterrence posture, he said. “Rather, as I said, it signals a shift towards more first use capable posture,” Mr Sattar said. “The future strategic stability in South Asia is placed on a perilous and worrisome course with heightened risk of misunderstanding and miscalculation, potentially leading to unintended or accidental escalation to the nuclear level,” he added. Published in Dawn, October 21st, 2026
Pakistan warns India against attempt to alter strategic balanceRubio says India made 'substantial progress' in diversifying oil purchases
US Secretary of State Marco Rubio said on Tuesday that India had made “substantial progress” in diversifying its energy supplies, including away from its key importer, Russia. “What India has expressed repeatedly is their desire to diversify their energy portfolio, which is a smart thing to do,” Rubio said on a visit to India’s economic capital, Mumbai. “Obviously, it’s not easy to do that from one day to the next, so I think they’ve made substantial progress in that regard, and we’re happy to see that.” This is Rubio’s second official visit to the country this year, as he pursues an Asian tour blending diplomacy and trade. He has visited Uzbekistan, where he called for stronger partnerships with Central Asian countries, before landing in Mumbai for talks with Foreign Minister Subrahmanyam Jaishankar and meetings with business leaders. India is a major importer of Russian oil, and US President Donald Trump’s tariff war launched in April last year has added to friction between Washington and New Delhi. “Obviously, we think we could be a source of some of their energy inputs,” Rubio said. The top US diplomat will visit Jamnagar, in the western state of Gujarat, a port and stronghold of billionaire Mukesh Ambani’s Reliance conglomerate and its flagship refinery, the world’s largest. “India is a refining superpower,” said Rubio. Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi is not scheduled to meet Rubio this time. Washington’s top diplomat is also due to lay a wreath in memory of the 2008 Mumbai attacks that killed 166 people. The top US diplomat visited New Delhi and Kolkata in May this year, while also touring the Taj Mahal and meeting Modi. Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky said on Tuesday he had also spoken to Rubio and raised issues with the US military satellite system that Ukraine uses, as well as missile delays. Zelensky, expected in Oslo for talks with US envoys, said he told Rubio that “Starlink/Starshield needs to be restored” and that ballistic missile interceptors “are needed to protect lives”. ‘Energy supplies’ Rubio’s visit comes as India and the United States struggle to finalise a trade deal, a persistent source of friction between the two countries. “We’re very very close; I would say we’re about as close as you can be without having an executed agreement. I think there’s a small number of items left to wrap up,” Rubio said. “Hopefully have some good news to announce fairly soon, and perhaps the leaders can sign it thereafter.” Speaking in Samarkand earlier this week, Rubio said Washington and New Delhi were “very close” to an agreement. However, a deal during his visit appears unlikely. Asked about temporary US sanctions waivers for Russian oil, Rubio said Washington had to juggle multiple factors “including our bilateral relationships with other countries and what they realistically are capable of being able to do in terms of their own energy supplies”. “You also can’t unravel the economy of other countries because of one central issue,” he said. The two countries reached an interim trade agreement in February aimed at reducing US tariffs on Indian goods. But days later, the US Supreme Court struck down Trump’s sweeping tariffs, fuelling uncertainty over when the agreement would take effect. The two sides have been negotiating ever since. Indian Finance Minister Nirmala Sitharaman said this month the talks had reached “a plateau, beyond which giving or taking might be very, very difficult”. Jaishankar met with his United Arab Emirates counterpart in Mumbai earlier on Tuesday. The UAE is a key supplier of Indian energy, especially liquefied natural gas (LNG). “The situation in the Gulf remains a matter of deep concern,” Jaishankar told UAE Foreign Minister Sheikh Abdullah bin Zayed Al Nahyan, in public comments broadcast before their meeting started. He said India continues to support “free, safe and unimpeded flow of trade, energy and fertiliser”.
ABD-İran Mutabakatına Rağmen İsrail'den Lübnan'a Kanlı Saldırı: 4 ÖlüRubio lands in India for 'trade diplomacy'
US Secretary of State Marco Rubio arrived in India on Tuesday, his second official visit to the country this year, as he pursues an Asian tour blending diplomacy and trade. Rubio visited Uzbekistan, where he called for stronger partnerships with Central Asian countries, before landing in Mumbai for talks with Foreign Minister Subrahmanyam Jaishankar and meetings with business leaders. The top US diplomat visited New Delhi and Kolkata in May, while also touring the Taj Mahal and meeting Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi. Modi is not scheduled to meet Rubio this time. The top US diplomat will visit Jamnagar, in the western state of Gujarat, a port and stronghold of billionaire Mukesh Ambani’s Reliance conglomerate — including its key refinery, the world’s largest. He is also due to lay a wreath in memory of the 2008 Mumbai attacks that killed 166 people. Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky said on Tuesday he had also spoken to Rubio and raised issues with the US military satellite system that Ukraine uses, as well as missile delays. Zelensky, expected in Oslo for talks with US envoys, said he told Rubio that “Starlink/Starshield needs to be restored” and that ballistic missile interceptors “are needed to protect lives”. ‘Energy supplies’ Rubio’s visit comes as India and the United States struggle to finalise a trade deal, a persistent source of friction between the two countries. Speaking in Samarkand, Rubio said Washington and New Delhi were “very close” to an agreement. However, a deal during his visit appears unlikely. US President Donald Trump’s tariff war launched in April last year has added to friction over India’s imports of Russian oil and warming ties between Washington and Pakistan, India’s arch-rival. Asked about temporary US sanctions waivers for Russian oil, of which India is a major importer, Rubio said Washington had to juggle multiple factors “including our bilateral relationships with other countries and what they realistically are capable of being able to do in terms of their own energy supplies”. “You also can’t unravel the economy of other countries because of one central issue,” he said. The two countries reached an interim trade agreement in February aimed at reducing US tariffs on Indian goods. But days later, the US Supreme Court struck down Trump’s sweeping tariffs, fuelling uncertainty over when the agreement would take effect. The two sides have been negotiating ever since. Indian Finance Minister Nirmala Sitharaman said this month the talks had reached “a plateau, beyond which giving or taking might be very, very difficult”. Jaishankar met with his United Arab Emirates counterpart in Mumbai earlier on Tuesday. The UAE is a key supplier of Indian energy, especially liquefied natural gas (LNG). “The situation in the Gulf remains a matter of deep concern,” Jaishankar told UAE Foreign Minister Sheikh Abdullah bin Zayed Al Nahyan, in public comments broadcast before their meeting started. He said India continues to support “free, safe and unimpeded flow of trade, energy and fertiliser”.
What is holding up the US-India trade deal?She was harassed for crude remarks about Modi at a Cockroach protest. Now she can’t leave home
After a protest clip went viral, a teenager’s life was torn apart by threats that sent her and her family into hiding. Plus, a book on citizen journalism Before 24 July, a person I will call R was preoccupied with the ordinary routines of teenage life: experimenting with makeup, grumbling over mathematics homework and hanging out with friends at a tea stall. That month, as the fever of student protests spread across the country, the 15-year-old watched on her phone as young people poured into Jantar Mantar, the designated protest site in Delhi, demanding education reform. She went too. But an 11-second video clip from the protest site, in which she made crude and profane remarks about the prime minister, Narendra Modi, upended her life. Continue reading...
Declared dead: Indian voters fight to get back on electoral rolls
Kamta Prasad has been shuttling between government offices in Delhi trying to prove he is not dead. The 53-year-old tailor is among 130 million names removed from India’s electoral rolls under a voter roll revision that has sparked mass protests and posed the biggest challenge to Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s government. The Special Intensive Revision (SIR) has led to removals for reasons ranging from “logical discrepancies” to people being recorded as dead, leaving many such as Prasad struggling to get more than just their voting status restored. He has had to forgo his daily wage of 250 Indian rupees that supports his family of four to scurry around the city to reverse the error. “I panicked when I heard about it,” said Prasad, who is among 4.2 million Delhi voters struck off the list, according to the draft rolls published by the poll body on August 31. “Since then I’ve been going everywhere to prove that I’m alive.” Kamta Prasad, 53, a voter who is listed as “Kanta Prasad” and is declared dead in the Special Intensive Revision (SIR) list published on August 1, 2026, cleans his glasses at his workstation, in New Delhi, India on October 19, 2026. —Reuters The deletions have triggered a political storm, with opposition parties and youth groups staging near-daily protests in New Delhi and elsewhere, which have been met with force by the police. They allege Election Commission chief Gyanesh Kumar manipulated the revision to benefit Modi’s Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP), a charge denied by both the commission and the BJP. ‘Nobody listens’ According to Rajendra Kumar, a volunteer with non-profit Jan Sarokar, about 2,000 of the roughly 9,000 voters in Prasad’s block were struck off after the revision, classified as absent, shifted, deceased or registered elsewhere. Prasad is the only person in this block who has been declared dead but several similar cases have been reported by local media across the country. The Election Commission has said it was removing duplicate, deceased, shifted and otherwise ineligible voters and that anyone excluded in error can file claims, submit supporting documents and pursue appeals before the rolls are finalised. For voters such as Prasad, however, exclusion leads to a bureaucratic maze, and depending on the circumstances they may have to provide proof of life, establish residency, correct alleged discrepancies or submit fresh documentation. That involves repeated visits to election offices, hearings before electoral officials and multiple rounds of appeals, with some spending weeks or months trying to restore their names. “I told them I voted in the last assembly and general elections and have been voting for 35 years, but nobody listens,” Prasad said. India’s Election Commission did not reply to a request for comment for this story. Register as a new voter Following weeks of protests, the Election Commission ordered fresh verification in some states, including Delhi, and Prasad said officials had assured him his name would be restored. Kamal Lal, a 38-year-old private school teacher in Delhi, was marked as “shifted” even though he still lives in a settlement beneath a flyover with dozens of other families. Kamal Lal, 38, a teacher and voter who says his name was removed from the voter list and is placed in the Permanently Shifted category in the Special Intensive Revision (SIR) list, stands below a flyover in New Delhi, India on October 16, 2026. —Reuters “It is very disappointing that we have been voting in this country and now our names have been cut because we do not have land papers or a water bill,” he said. Lal said he first learned of his exclusion in September and has since approached election officials, attended hearings and filed multiple reinstatement applications. For some excluded voters, the remedy offered by officials has brought little comfort: rather than restoring their previous registrations, they were advised to apply afresh as new voters. For poorer voters, fears run even deeper. Mamta, a voter whose name was removed from the voter list and put under the Permanently Shifted category in the Special Intensive Revision (SIR) list published on August 1, 2026, poses for a photograph during a Reuters interview at her house in New Delhi, India on October 15, 2026. —Reuters “Now local election officials are asking us to register as new voters, and my husband is strongly opposed to that because he has voted in the last few elections,” said 39-year-old Mamta, who does not use a surname. “I am worried that if our names are not restored to the list, I could lose access to subsidised ration and other government welfare schemes.” Header image: Kamta Prasad, 53, a voter who is listed as “Kanta Prasad” and is declared dead in the Special Intensive Revision (SIR) list published on August 1, 2026, walks through an alley in New Delhi, India on October 19, 2026. —Reuters
Declared dead: Indian voters fight to get back on electoral rollsRubio heads to India for 'trade diplomacy'
US Secretary of State Marco Rubio heads to India on Tuesday for his second official visit to the country this year, as he pursues an Asian tour blending diplomacy and trade. After a trip to Uzbekistan, where he called for stronger partnerships with Central Asian countries, Rubio will head to Mumbai to hold talks with Foreign Minister Subrahmanyam Jaishankar and meet business leaders. The top US diplomat visited New Delhi and Kolkata in May, while also touring the Taj Mahal and meeting Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi. No meeting with Modi is planned during this trip, which will also take Rubio to Jamnagar, in the western state of Gujarat, a port and stronghold of billionaire Mukesh Ambani’s Reliance conglomerate — including its key refinery, the world’s largest. He is also expected to lay a wreath in memory of the 2008 Mumbai attacks that killed 166 people. Rubio’s visit comes as the two countries struggle to finalise a trade deal that has been a source of repeated tensions. Speaking in Samarkand on Monday, he said Washington and New Delhi were “very close” to an agreement. However, the prospects of securing a deal during this visit appeared slim. US President Donald Trump’s tariff war launched in April last year has added to friction over India’s imports of Russian oil and warming ties between Washington and Pakistan, India’s arch-rival. Asked about temporary US sanctions waivers for Russian oil, of which India is a major importer, Rubio said Washington had to juggle multiple factors “including our bilateral relationships with other countries and what they realistically are capable of being able to do in terms of their own energy supplies”. “You also can’t unravel the economy of other countries because of one central issue,” he said. The two countries reached an interim trade agreement in February aimed at reducing US tariffs on Indian goods. But days later, the US Supreme Court struck down Trump’s sweeping tariffs, fuelling uncertainty over when the agreement would take effect. The two sides have been negotiating since. Indian Finance Minister Nirmala Sitharaman this month described the talks as having reached “a plateau, beyond which giving or taking might be very, very difficult”.
What is holding up the US-India trade deal?